OK, so I know I'm not an expert. I was sitting in a preschool orientation meeting with Megan's preschool teacher earlier this fall and listening to how the teachers discipline at school: get down on a child's level, use a calm voice, explain (or even better, get the child to explain) the problem, and then help the child come up with some resolutions. Also, if behavior persists, distract the child or remove the child from the situation.
My friend sitting next to me has a son the same age as Zoë, and a second son a little younger than Megan. She leaned over and whispered to me, "You know, after this meeting I go home and for about a week I use these skills, and then it's right back out the window!"
For me it was a refreshing wake-up call. I used to be so effective at this with Zoë, and moderately so with Megan, but even less with Miranda. Poor Veronica! So, I'm back to trying again to use these techniques.
Yes, I still spend too much time yelling, something I'm not proud of and trying to work on. And, with my efforts, I have seen a wonderful response. In myself! I'm not as upset and frustrated because I've taken out the emotion on my side. I feel more patient (most of the time). I've also found that having a good night's sleep is helpful- for both me and the kid.
When I read this article in the New York Times, I had to laugh. Are there seriously parents out there who don't know how to be the Alpha? That is SO not a problem in my family! I grew up in a house full of Indian Chiefs, as my mom liked to call us girls and my dad, and no Indians. My current family is not dissimilar (although my girls' dad is MUCH more laid back, he still has that iron fist in a kid glove- so they know not to push him too far).
I know many people who have (had) dogs and children, and most of them say that training a dog is not too dissimilar from raising a young child. So, there is some merit to the idea of using similar techiniqes. I especially love the quote at the end of the article:
“This is good?” she wrote. “Did I have that attitude as a parent? Was I focusing on the positives, the opportunities?..."
Some of my best parenting moments are when a child, who knows she has done something wrong, will come to me and say, "Sorry, mama!" and put her arms around me. If I've disciplined properly, I am also in the mood to receive that apology, and both of us benefit from the greater love we show each other.